🔗 Share this article

Supporters for a private school system established to instruct Hawaiian descendants portray a recent legal action attacking the acceptance policies as a blatant effort to ignore the wishes of a royal figure who left her fortune to ensure a brighter future for her community nearly 140 years ago.

The Tradition of the Royal Benefactor

The Kamehameha schools were established through the testament of Bernice Pauahi Bishop, the great-granddaughter of Kamehameha I and the final heir in the royal family. At the time of her death in 1884, the her holdings included approximately 9% of the archipelago's total acreage.

Her will founded the learning institutions using those estate assets to fund them. Currently, the system encompasses three sites for elementary through high school and 30 preschools that emphasize Hawaiian culture-based education. The institutions educate approximately 5,400 learners from kindergarten to 12th grade and have an financial reserve of approximately $15 billion, a sum greater than all but about 10 of the country’s most elite universities. The schools take no money from the U.S. treasury.

Rigorous Acceptance and Financial Support

Entrance is extremely selective at all grades, with only about 20% students being accepted at the secondary school. Kamehameha schools also fund roughly 92% of the price of teaching their learners, with nearly 80% of the student body additionally obtaining different types of financial aid based on need.

Background History and Cultural Significance

An expert, the head of the indigenous education department at the the state university, said the Kamehameha schools were established at a time when the indigenous community was still on the downward trend. In the late 1880s, about 50,000 indigenous people were estimated to live on the Hawaiian chain, reduced from a peak of between 300,000 to half a million inhabitants at the era of first contact with Westerners.

The Hawaiian monarchy was truly in a unstable position, particularly because the America was increasingly more and more interested in establishing a permanent base at the harbor.

The scholar noted throughout the 1900s, “almost everything Hawaiian was being sidelined or even removed, or forcefully subdued”.

“During that era, the Kamehameha schools was genuinely the single resource that we had,” the academic, a graduate of the institutions, commented. “The institution that we had, that was exclusively for our people, and had the capacity at the very least of ensuring we kept pace with the rest of the population.”

The Court Case

Today, nearly every one of those registered at the centers have Native Hawaiian ancestry. But the new suit, filed in the courts in the capital, says that is inequitable.

The lawsuit was filed by a group named the plaintiff organization, a conservative group based in the state that has for decades pursued a legal battle against race-conscious policies and race-based admissions practices. The association took legal action against the prestigious college in 2014 and eventually obtained a landmark high court decision in 2023 that led to the conservative judges eliminate race-conscious admissions in colleges and universities across the nation.

A website established last month as a forerunner to the court case indicates that while it is a “outstanding learning institution”, the schools’ “enrollment criteria openly prioritizes students with indigenous heritage rather than non-Native Hawaiian students”.

“Actually, that priority is so strong that it is practically not possible for a non-Native Hawaiian student to be accepted to the institutions,” the group states. “It is our view that priority on lineage, as opposed to merit or need, is neither fair nor legal, and we are dedicated to terminating the institutions' unlawful admissions policies in court.”

Political Efforts

The campaign is spearheaded by Edward Blum, who has overseen organizations that have filed over twelve court cases challenging the consideration of ethnicity in schooling, industry and in various organizations.

Blum did not reply to journalistic inquiries. He told a news organization that while the group endorsed the educational purpose, their offerings should be accessible to all Hawaiians, “not just those with a certain heritage”.

Educational Implications

An education expert, a scholar at the education department at Stanford, explained the legal action aimed at the Kamehameha schools was a remarkable case of how the battle to roll back historic equality laws and policies to foster equitable chances in schools had moved from the arena of colleges and universities to K-12.

The professor stated right-leaning organizations had challenged the prestigious university “quite deliberately” a decade ago.

In my view the challenge aims at the Kamehameha schools because they are a particularly distinct establishment… similar to the way they picked Harvard with clear intent.

The scholar said while preferential treatment had its detractors as a fairly limited tool to expand academic chances and entry, “it served as an crucial tool in the toolbox”.

“It was a component of this more extensive set of regulations obtainable to schools and universities to increase admission and to create a fairer learning environment,” the professor said. “To lose that mechanism, it’s {incredibly harmful